RMBS Limbo Losses ll (May 2011)

In valuing secondary market RMBS over the years, R&R discovered many servicer reporting irregularities on collateral losses. At year-end 2011, we decided to generalize our observations on the total market. We presented our findings on January 25, 2012, in “RMBS Losses in Limbo: As Bad as They Seem, The Reality May Be Much Worse.” Our press release was picked up in Naked Capitalism, “Yes, Virginia, Servicers Lie to Investors, Too” and a number of other publications.

R&R received many inquiries about our research conclusions. These are the basis of a follow-on piece, available from today, that provides additional detail on our analysis and findings. In our report, we demonstrate the application of limbo loss analysis to four transactions:

  1. Countrywide ABS 2006-SPS2
  2. MASTR Asset Backed Securitizations Trust 2006-HE
  3. Structure Asset Securities Corp Series 2006-S4
  4. Asset Backed Funding Corp 2006-OPT3

We draw the following key conclusions:

  • Limbo losses arise from timing mismatches in the amortization and liquidation of nonperforming mortgage loans.
  • While some limbo losses are a natural artifact of the mortgage servicing process and can be manually reconciled, a significant number of limbo losses in the years 2005-2007 (and some during 2003-2004) appear to be strategic, permitting the servicer to prefer some liability holders over others without easy detection.
  • Our small sample of reconciled transactions did not significantly alter our original numbers–$175 MM of limbo losses due to timing differences between assets and liabilities and $125 MM of limbo losses due to a build up in the trust of non-performing loans that are not being liquidated.

Please contact Iuliia Palamar (iuliia.palamar@creditspectrum.com) if you would like to receive a copy of Losses in Limbo – February 2012.

Tags: , ,

Trackback from your site.

Comments (1)

  • avram


    please see how orix still money from cmbs


Leave a comment


Smiley face

Latest Post:

Automatic Synthesis of Tri-Diagonal Markov Transition Matrices: A Failure of the Inverse Ferron-Frobenius AlgorithmABSTRACT: Sylvain Raynes experimented with a method developed by Goya and Boyarski (1993) to standardize the synthesis of conditional Markov transition matrices for deal entry in our automated re-rating system, ABSTRAK®. In the analytical literature, the reverse-engineering of a Markov matrix from its spectral-radius eigenvector is referred to as the Inverse Perron-Frobenius Problem. Our analysts do this synthesis manually, so a successful outcome […]

Click for all posts

Film Fund-amentals

Smiley face

Latest Post:

The Relativity ImplosionRelativity Media’s descent into bankruptcy has been spiraling for many years, almost since its beginning according to some analysts. When the company first emerged back in 2004, it was greeted with a mixture of high hope and deep doubt. Relativity promised new approaches and a vague claim to modern scientific methodology but was thin on the details. The early years […]

Click for all posts

R&R on China

Smiley face

Latest Post:


Click for all posts